John Brown's Notes and Essays
Wednesday, April 30, 2014
Propaganda and Under Secretary of State for Public Diplomacy Stengel: An Exchange
An exchange on Facebook
Nice to see the Undersecretary taking a direct role in addressing RT's propaganda.
Russia's Propaganda Channel Just Got A Journalism Lesson From The US State Department
The State Department continues its war of words with RT.
BUSINESS INSIDER
Like
·
·
Share
3 people
like this.
Matthew Wallin
Except this statement is flat out wrong: "Propaganda is the deliberate dissemination of information that you know to be false or misleading in order to influence an audience." As we all know, propaganda can be perfectly truthful information.
4 hrs
·
Like
Craig Hayden
It's not wrong. It's just a specific interpretation of what propaganda means. I think it's hard to argue that propaganda can still be a neutral analytical term (despite the heroic efforts of some scholars). It's a rhetorical device, ripe for leveraging its connotations when describing the communication of others.
4 hrs
·
Like
·
3
Craig Hayden
So yeah, read Jay Black's "Semantics and Ethics of Propaganda" for the distinction.
4 hrs
·
Like
Matthew Wallin
It can also very easily involve deliberately leaving out certain information, and presenting only your side of the story. Then I suppose the question is, what does "misleading" mean?
4 hrs
·
Like
·
1
Lena Osipova-Stocker
everyone does it:
http://lena-globalchaos.blogspot.com/.../infowar-over...
Global Chaos: InfoWar over Ukraine - from sad to ridiculous
lena-globalchaos.blogspot.com
4 hrs
·
Like
Aimee Fullman
And we'll all be using this to discuss propaganda in our classrooms:)
3 hrs
·
Like
John Brown
I'll all in favor of improperganda
! Just kiddin'
BTW, in Stengel's comments, as recorded in the cited article, the journalist who's reinvented himself as Under Secretary of State for Public Diplomacy doesn't really "break down his definitions of th
e differences between news, opinion, and propaganda." What is "news," Mr. Stengel? Some call it "the shock troops of propaganda." What do you say to that? Arguably -- or should I say *very" arguably -- Time Magazine, for which Stengel gave his soul, is propaganda posing as information; or, as a learned scholar once called it, "canned information" to be consumed like a Big Mac rather than factual analysis stimulating thought. True, the blatant propagandizing of the Cold War-era Time Magazine, which celebrated the American way of life ad nauseam, has become more "balanced" in our new century; or as cynics might put it, has made its propaganda for corporate America/advertisers (labeled, in overused words, as "American values" and "the American way of life") more "subtle" due to the increased "sophistication" (i.e., access to many sources of information, largely due to the Internet) of its declining audience. Stengel, God bless him, is part of a crowd of slightly over-the-hill scribblers hoping to earn a few more dollars by working for the Federal government as political appointees before old age completely creeps up on them. (But then don't we have enough over-paid "spokespersons" from the State Department, the White House, DoD pontificating about the U.S. and condemning the Evil Other? for the MSM longing for "news" to be consumed.)
Well, to put it more diplomatically and to give credit to a fellow Princetonian (I went to Princeton as a grad student), Rick now wants to serve his country -- after getting a reported miserly up to 250K bonus
http://www.washingtontimes.com/.../former-editors.../...
(peanuts in corporate America) from Time, Inc.
Former Time editor Stengel got big bonus while laying off reporters, heading to State Department
www.washingtontimes.com
Not long before he left his job as managing editor at Time magazine for a post a
t the State Department, Richard Stengel delivered some bad but not unexpected news — the magazine needed to cut staff to close a budget gap.
3 hrs
·
Edited
·
Like
·
Remove Preview
Christopher Dufour
If it's Russian, it's probably propaganda, yo.
2 mins
·
Like
No comments:
Post a Comment
‹
›
Home
View web version
No comments:
Post a Comment